Navpreet Chhina Achieves Successful Result at Worker’s Compensation Appeal Tribunal

Navpreet Chhina recently obtained a successful result at the Workers Compensation Appeal Tribunal, following an oral appeal hearing.

In this matter, the Tribunal confirmed that, pursuant to Workers Compensation Act paragraph 135(1)(c), a worker’s claim for compensation for a mental disorder will be denied if the mental disorder was caused by bona fide decisions of management related to the worker’s employment. The Tribunal noted that a such decisions of management need not be “correct” or perfectly “fair” to still engage the exclusion. The decisions of management in question at the hearing were reprimands for safety infractions, training issues, and a demotion.

Without this provision of the Act, the Tribunal recognized that employers may find it difficult to manage their workforce without being vulnerable to mental stress claims, and specifically noted that “the purpose behind this exclusion is to recognize that employment is often highly personal and that conflict may arise between an employer and a worker in managing the employment relationship. Thus, as long as an employer is acting in a bona fide way in exercising its management rights, any resulting mental stress is not compensable.”

Inlet Law is currently taking on new clients. To schedule a free initial consultation for your employment matter, call 604-394-6538, or email

This article does not contain legal advice.

Martin Sheard assisted me, and his work was first-rate. He was knowledgeable, efficient, and made me absolutely confident that I had received exactly the legal services I needed.
— Joe Broadhurst / Managing Partner, Broadhurst Kooy Family Law

Learn More

Martin Sheard has advocated at the Supreme Court of Canada on behalf of financially marginalized Canadians. Only about once every two years does the Supreme Court of Canada hear an employment law case, so this was a special moment for Martin.